December 15, 2020
Indian Pennies on Dime Planchets probably about 12-15 known
1863 Kagin 6/68 lot 718, 77 ANA lot 4479, B/R 6/78 lot 1379 at $450
1864-L reported by Taxay from Adams & Woodin (dubious)
1868 reported by Taxay
1869 Woodin?, Brenner-1914 ANS, Brand (journal #92500:825), Olsen (Mehl 11/44), Federal Coin 5/59 lot 2196 - later to Superior 9/98 lot 829 ANACS net AU50 at $5750, Tony Terranova, Mike Byers, Heritage 1/12 at $25,300 - PCGSAU55 cleaned - if unique
1883 over a struck dime, reported by Taxay
1893 reported by Taxay
1899 on an 1899 dime ex Mike Byers 1975 FPL, stolen from Mark Lighterman in 2001 and recovered 2009 NGCAU58 #1886094-004
1900 Kagin 9/67 lot 375, 77 ANA lot 4484, Schornstein, HIM 11/82 at $2,600, Xan Chamberlain NGC66 #1726780-007 25% off-center and double struck
1903 over a struck dime, reported by Taxay
1905 Listed as stolen from Mark Lighterman
1906 1) Chambers, Heritage 4/13 at $19,681 NGCXF45 #1816306-006 in 100 Greatest Mint Errors
2) eBay antiquesandmore 6/18 at $13,850, Ed Fuhrman NGCXF details reverse scratched #4694892-001
1908 Earle (H Chapman 1912 lot 2262)
one with a piece of copper struck into head stolen from Mark Lighterman in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC Unc details with horizontal scratch left to top of O in One on reverse #1886094-007
Note: one of these is lot 864 in Mehl's 11/22/1921, ditto Shinkle (Morgenthau 4/32 lot 115)
1909 1) Cohen-Halpern FPL, Weinberg PCGSAU58
2) overstruck on a 1906 dime, Heritage 9/06 at $37,375, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 3/13(not sold), StacksBowers 8/13 ANA at $42,594 NGC65
Lincoln Cents struck over Mercury Dimes
1943 1) B/R 5/73 Terrell sale lot 1092
2) Fivas (imaged on cover of MECCA 4/73), 2003 ANA lot 3217 at $21,850, Heritage 8/06 lot 4013 at $28,750, Walter-StacksBowers 8/18 ANA lot 1403 at $33,600 PCGS62 flipover
1945-S John Devine, flipover obverse imaged in MECCA 4/75, Schornstein
Note: The 1944-D in HIM 11/82 Unc was withdrawn and appears to be fake.
Cents on Quarter Eagle Planchets
Indian
1900 1) HIM 11/82?, Heritage 8/93 ANA - AU, 67.12 grains
2) Col Green ?, Kreisberg 1/75, Superior Auction 89, B/M 8/91 ANA, Mike Byers-Heritage 4/15 - PCGS65, 65.8 grains
3) reported by Mike Hodder
One of these is ex Dewitt Smith, Brand (journal id #46973), consigned to BGJ 10/8/35 & 1/19/42 graded VF (called UNC when sent to Stacks 3/24/42 at $210)
1905 1) ex Heritage 1/10 FUN, Mike Byers-Heritage 8/14 (not sold), Heritage 12/14 (not sold), Heritage 1/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/15 (not sold), Heritage 9/15 - PCGS64 64.5 grains
1906 1) ex Stacks 6/04, Stacks 9/09, Nick Brown, Brown estate - NGCAU58, 64.4 grains
1907 1) ex Kosoff, Mertes purchased at the 1952 ANA
Lincoln
1911 reported by Taxay
1915 ex Col Green, BG Johnson (Kelly 1/3/44 invoice at $200), JV McDermott
1927 reported by Taxay
2 Cent on One Cent Planchets probably 13-15 known
1864LM 1) Copper Nickel reported by Taxay
2) Bronze Weinberg Fall 78 FPL as 1867 !!, Numismatics LTD Spring 1982 FPL, Xan Chamberlain, Heritage 1/07 at
$8,050, Mike Byers, Heritage 4/10 at $7,475 - NGCAU58BN
3) Numismatics LTD Spring 1981 FPL full date AU (bronze? otherwise same as 1)
4) Bolt collection flipover on struck cent, Weinberg Summer 79 FPL VF (bronze?)
1865 1) Bolt, Cohen-Halpern FPL, B/M 1/85 stolen from Mark Lighterman in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC64RB, centered
2) Heritage 8/15 ANA at $9,400 PCGSXF45, corroded
3) F. Leone NGC64RB left side at 10:00 missing
4) F. Leone off-center in ANACS holder
5) F. Leone slightly corroded in ANACS holder
1866 1) 77 ANA, Schornstein-HIM 7/83 UNC at $1000 to Frank Leone ?
1869 1) Reported by Taxay
1871 1) F. Leone
No date 1) Mike Byers
2 Cent on Shield Nickels Planchets
1870 1) Reported by Taxay
1871 1) Weinberg 4/02 as net VF scratched, ANR 7/03 at $10,350, Northeast Numismatics, Mike Byers, Goldberg 2/07 at $8050 (not sold), Heritage 5/07 (not sold), Weinberg FPL 2007-9 - NCS AU details, scratched, Heritage 7/09 - $4,888
2) Bolt, Cohen-Halpern FPL?, Schornstein, Weinberg Summer 1984 FPL, F. Leone
1872 1) Reported by Taxay and Judd
Two Cent Piece Struck on a Three Cent Nickel planchet
1865 stolen from Mark Lighterman
Shield Nickels on Cent Planchets probably 11-12 known
1866 1) Sanford (E Cogan 1874 lot 80 to Herbert), much later to Federal Coin 5/59 lot 2196 as XF, Superior 9/98 lot 854 as XF at $4600, Jim O'Donnell, Superior 2/01, Mike Byers, Heritage 4/10 (not sold), Heritage 8/10 (not sold) - PCGSXF45
2) Seavey Descriptive Catalog (1873) #1048, Parmelee (1890) part of lot 165 ?, much later to Federal Coin Exchange 8/60 lot 2442 as Unc, Schornstein, stolen from Mark Lighterman in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC64BN #1886094-008, overgraded
Note: Others likely. It is possible that the 2 Federal Coin listings belong to only one of these instead of being split.
1867 w/rays 1) Seavey Descriptive Catalog (1873) #1056, Parmelee (1890) part of lot 175, unknown intermediates, more recently
Weinberg Summer 1979 FPL, Ed Saunders, Jerry Bobbe, Kagins 11/98, Saul Teichman 12/98 ANACS64BN at $5000 Unique, finest of type!
No date w/rays stolen from Mark Lighterman
1867 n/rays Federal Coin Exchange 8/60 lot 2443 VF
1868 reported by Judd & Taxay
1871 H Chapman 7/22/25 lot 1011 at $2.75
1873 1) closed 3 Zabriskie (1909) lot 312, (to A F Holden ie Norweb family), Olsen, Farouk, Weinberg personal collection PCGS62 now crossed over and NCS'd
2) open 3 ANS 0000.999.55686, corroded, 2.969 grams - verification pending, may be a contemporary counterfeit
1876 1) Bolt, Weinberg, private collection - PCGSAU50
1882 1) Elder 2/25/1909 lot 37, Elder 11/37 (a Chicago collector) lot 1189, Xan Chamberlain NGC65BN #1770620-002 weakly struck
2) VF reported by Glen Burger, Heritage 9/02 at $2,070, Weinberg, Mike Byers, Als Coins, Heritage 1/07 (not sold) as NCS AU details, cleaned, Heritage 4/14 (additional rehab) at $8,519 - PCGSAU55
No date stolen from Mark Lighterman
Shield Nickels on Nickel 3 Cent Planchets
1868 1) Heritage 2006 ANA, XF corroded (not sold), Weinberg 11/07, Heritage 1/09 NCS AU details cleaned up at $1,610,
Heritage 7/09 at $1,725 (note: Brand had one of this date from Chapman 8/22/16 sale journal #80897 at $2)
ND 1) Mike Byers 1975 price list, Schornstein (plate 13) to Mark Lighterman, stolen in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC63?
2) 77 ANA
See also Stacks 10/76 UNC weak below 5, Fall 1978 Weinberg FPL, Weinberg summer 1984 FPL for additional appearances of these undated pieces. 2 were in the Bolt collection.
V Nickels on Cent Planchets - probably 60 or so known
1883NC 1) PC Clark (Bolender 11/32 lot 859) as AU, 58 ANA lot 443 as XF ?, Federal Coin Exchange 8/60 lot 2444 as Unc, 64 ANA lot 733 Unc, Cohen-Halpern FPL, B/R 1/85 Unc at $1210 are there two coins here or is it unique?
2) circulated - eBay April 2011 by E-adventure II/Paperchasesue would like to see this piece slabbed, might be a fake.
3) ANA museum - 1989.0135.0017 also corroded, is this genuine ?, looks fake to me and Fred Weinberg
1886 1) NERCA 11/81 VF
2) Schornstein, appears AU or better (could be an 1896)
1888 1) Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 FPL Xan Chamberlain, Heritage 1/07 at $4744 - NGC64BN
2) Green 6/29/06 lot 374 circulated
1889 1) Overstruck on an 1873 indian cent, see September 2002 edition of Coin World.
2) Heritage 1/2005 ANACSF12, Weinberg now PCGSF15, Heritage 8/19 ANA at $2520, Sullivan offered at $3,000
3) Greg Bennick - PCGSF12
4) Heritage 4/12 at $1,840, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $2,640 - NGCAU50 details cleaned
1890 1) Rausch-Heritage 8/04 - ANACSVG8
2) Federal Coin Exchange 8/60 lot 2445 VF
1892 1) Cohen-Halpern FPL, Numismatics Ltd Spring 1983 FPL, Jim's Coins May 2007 ANACS58BN,
StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $5,040 NGC63BN #1583700-001
1893 1) Weinberg 3/99, 99 ANA (not sold), StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 8/19 ANA at $3,120 - PCGSXF40 #3397600
2) Smithsonian (279171.001)
3) eBay May 2012, May 2015, Jon Sullivan PCGSXF45 #03538381
Note: one of these is ex-PC Clark lot 868 as VF and/or Bolender's 86th. Newcomer had one. The 100 Greatest Mint Errors example could be another if it is not #2.
1894 1) Weinberg at 2015 ANA VF scratched
1895 1) Superior 9/06 - PCGSVF35
1896 1) 64 ANA lot 734 as VF, Weinberg Spring 1981 FPL, Weinberg 3/02 FPL as PCGSAU50, Heritage 9/05, 1/06 StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 8/19 ANA at $3,360 - PCGSAU53 probably 2 coins here.
1897 1) Weinberg 12/98 FPL Unc, Weinberg 9/99 FPL, Weinberg 2004 FPLs - PCGSAU55
1898 1) Weinberg 12/98 FPL XF, Weinberg 9/99 FPL, Saul Teichman for $2600 - PCGSAU55
1899 1) Weinberg 11/06, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $4,800 PCGSAU58, #08661885 illustrated on cover of MECCA 4/75
1900 1) Charles "Suitcase" Foster (1950s dealer), unknown intermediates, Sullivan 10/19, 9/20 inventory PCGSVF25 #38218063
1901 1) B/R 11/83 lot 2475 XF45, Leidman inventory 9/20/00 - ANACSAU50, eBay 9/00, Heritage 4/3/01 on-line auction, Rich Schemmer 4/02, B/M 9/02 at $4600 as NGCAU55BN, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 8/19 ANA at $3,000, Sullivan offered at $4,000 PCGSAU55BN #90075637, scratch below left pellet on reverse
2) NERCA 11/81 VF
3) Col Green?, Bolt UNC probably same as Rausch-Heritage 1/05 at $8,625, Heritage 6/05 at $5,463 - PCGS63BN
4) Rausch-Heritage 7/05 at $3,738, Weinberg 2006 inventory, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $3,120 - PCGSAU58BN #21726729
5) Heritage 8/12 at $1,998 NGC Unc details cleaned, Sullivan - PCGS62
See also Weinberg Summer 79 FPL.
1902 reported in Judd
1903 1) Numismatic Enterprises 2/68 lot 586 Unc, same as NGC Unc details cleaned #3837023-004, PCGS au details cleaned #37080701, Sullivan
1904 1) Weinberg 12/98 FPL AU, Weinberg 9/99 FPL, 2000 ANA, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $2,280 PCGSXF45 #5483288
2) Heritage 8/11 at $2,530 PCGSAU55BN
3) Heritage 4/13 at $3,525, Jon Sullivan PCGS62BN
1905 1) Weinberg 2004 FPLs PCGSAU50BN
One was listed in Elder 6/35 lot 1944 as Unc possibly same as above. Another on Philippine one centavo planchet
1906 1) Weinberg 3/99, Heritage 2/02 at $805, Weinberg, 2002 ANA as PCGS F15, Stacks 1/03 unslabbed, Heritage 8/19 ANA at $1,380, Sullivan offered at $2,300, Heritage 12/20 at $1,200 PCGSF15 - #3397601
2) Mike Byers 10/05 FPL, Weinberg 5/06 inventory, Walter-StacksBowers 8/18 ANA at $3,360, Sullivan PCGSXF45BN
3) Weinberg 3/02 FPL, Heritage 7/02, Heritage 8/04, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 9/20 at $,080 - PCGS63BN full date
4) Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 FPL ? Rich Schemmer at 96 ANA, Xan Chamberlain NGC65RB finest of type !!
5) Rausch-Heritage 8/04 - PCGS63BN partial date
6) Weinberg 11/05 FPL, Superior 8/06, Weinberg 11/06, Heritage 2007 ANA PCGSAU55
7) Heritage 1/09 at $3,738, Heritage 1/10 PCGSAU50
8) Weinberg at 2012 ANA, eBay 7/13 US coins online PCGSVF20
9) Heritage 12/12, Jon Sullivan PCGS XF details cleaned
10) Coast to Coast Coins 10/14 eBay, Sullivan 7/19, Heritage 8/20 at $2,160 PCGSVF30 #24947284
11) Sullivan 10/2019 NGC61BN #4837415-001
One of the UNC pieces is ex Brand journal #40155 at $10 from H Chapman 8/17/07, all 10 of those listed are different pieces
1907 1) Schornstein, Weinberg 1984 FPL, eBay in August 27, 2002, Weinberg, Heritage 9/05, Heritage 1/06, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $5,280 - PCGSAU58 #21628068
2) Weinberg Spring 1981 FPL, Superior 5/03, Early American History Auctions 8/03, 2/04 & 6/04 - ANACS Net VF20 scratched, now in a PCGSAU53 holder also offered in Teletrade 3/18/07, Teletrade 4/2/07, Teletrade 4/18/07, and various times on eBay, Heritage 9/16 has scratches left of face and C of Cents
3) B/M 2003 ANA - ANACS63BN
Newcomer had one.
1908 1) 91 ANA lot 722 Unc, 2000 ANA PCGS64
1910 1) B/M 2003 ANA Fine 12, Weinberg - PCGSF15
2) Mike Byers, Heritage 1/06, StacksBowers 3/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/20 at $4,800 - PCGSAU58 #21174323
1911 1) Federal Coin 9/55 lot 1039 VF, Federal Coin 8/60 lot 2447 XF, Superior 9/98 lot 855 AU/Unc, Jim O'Donnell, Superior 2/01, Weinberg, StacksBowers 3/15 at $4,700 - PCGSAU55 there could be 2 coins here.
Examples are also known on smaller cent sized copper-nickel planchets (usually South or Central American 5 centavo planchets). The most interesting of these is the 1891 2.9 grams 86.9% copper and 13.1% nickel as NGC63 piece ex Schemmer, Heritage 1/07 for $2300, Weinberg, Heritage 1/12 for $1,955 - PCGS63/NGC64. Apparently struck on the same stock as so-called pattern J-1758 !!
V Nickels on Dime Planchets
1901 Weinberg, Heritage 8/11 at $6,325 - NGCAU53 has some scratches
Taxay lists 1890, 1896, 1910 and 1911 in his 1976 Comprehensive Catalog.
Buffalo Nickels on Cent Planchets probably 50-60 known
1916 1) Seen at 2008 ANA and 2012 ANA PCGSAU58BN
1917 1) Park Avenue Numismatics website May 07 PCGS64BN for $27,360, Bob Hughes December 2009 Coin World article at $19,500 and then on eBay in April 2010 for $16,500.
2) eBay (Captivating coins) corroded with date well worn but either a 1917 or a 1913 !!
1918 about a half dozen known last one offered is 1) Heritage 1/05, 6/05 PCGSAU58BN 21723432, Weinberg, Heritage 1/09
1918-D 1) Entlich, Stacks 3/11 at $4888 - PCGSAU58
1918-S 1) HIM 11/82 - AU
1919 about a dozen known
1919-D 1) Bolt
2) GreatCollections 4/9/17 at $2,255 ANACSXF40 details scratched
1920 about 18-24 known including one 40% off-center ex Rausch-Heritage 8/04 at $17,250, Mike Byers, ANR/Stacks 11/06 (not sold), Heritage 8/07 at $17,250, StacksBowers 8/12 ANA (not sold), Heritage 1/15 FUN ($15,000 reserve), Heritage 4/17 at $12,338 PCGS64BN, another 25% off-center-Heritage 1/18 FUN at $11,400, Heritage 12/20 at $10,800 - NGC62BN
Nick Brown's NCS (NGC65RB) offered in Heritage 2/13 had $8500 ($9,988 with commission) DNS but sold after the sale, reoffered Heritage 11/14 and 1/15 FUN at $8,225, Heritage 4/17 at $13,338, Entlich's is PCGS61BN offered in 2013 ANA among others.
1921 1) Cohen-Halpern FPL, Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 FPL Gem Unc supposedly full red !!
1924 1) Federal Brand sale (64 ANA?), 77 ANA, 1978 Weinberg FPL, Heritage 9/08 at $11,500 - PCGS64BN, Nick Brown NCS'd now NGC65RB, Stacks-Bowers 3/13 at $9,988
2) Entlich as PCGSAU58, NCS'd - Heritage 3/13 at $4,259, Heritage 1/14 at $3,290, Jon Sullivan priced at $4,300 NGC62BN
3) Col Green, Newman-Heritage 4/13 at $28,200 NGC67RB
An example on a slightly larger and heavier copper planchet (foreign flan?) is ex Kelly 5/58 lot 1263
1925 1) Weinberg 7/04 Inventory - PCGS61BN
2) Mike Byers - NGCVG08
3) Weinberg Spring 1981 FPL, Heritage 5/09 ANACSXF40 at $2,760, Weinberg, eBay, Jon Sullivan as NGCVF30
4) Entlich, Stacks 3/11 at $5,635 (not sold), Stacks-Bowers 3/12 at $4,025- PCGSAU58, same as #1?
Weinberg summer 1979 FPL is either #1and/or #4
1925-D 1) Heritage 9/08 - NCSAU50 cleaned at $3,738
1927 1) Schornstein, Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPL ch AU, Entlich, StacksBowers 11/14 - PCGS60BN
1929 1) Heritage 4/05 withdrawn, Heritage 9/05 withdrawn, Heritage 1/06 at $9775 - PCGS64BN, probably ex 64 ANA
1934 1) Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPL as AU (#4?), Weinberg 3/02 FPL at $5000, Saul Teichman,
Heritage 6/06 at $4600, Weinberg 11/06 FPL, eBay 7/11 c5pete, Heritage 4/13 (new holder) at $3,525 NGC62BN
2) StacksBowers 3/18 NGC62BN full high date
3) Rausch-Heritage 8/04 at $4600, Saul Teichman PCGS63BN
4) Schornstein?, Entlich - PCGSAU50
5) August 11 eBay zacatak98, Xan Chamberlain eBay Sept 11, Teletrade 2/19/2012 at $2350, T Kemp? NGCAU58BN
#4069171-001
6) Mike Byers 10/04 ANACS63, possibly ex 83 ANA lot 4557, possibly one of above
7) Tyrone Kemp NGCAU58BN #5896618-001
One of these ex 64 ANA, and/or to 1978 Numismatics Ltd FPL (same as #2). A red example was in 1982 Numismatics Ltd FPL A toned Unc was in Kagin 83 ANA. Jon Sullivan has one in PCGSAU53, same as #4 or #5? Col Green had one.
1935 1) Bolt same as Rausch-Heritage 1/05 at $10,638 PCGS65RB
1936 1) 81 ANA XF, Heritage 6/17 at $3,290 PCGSAU55BN, (mintmark area not on planchet so could be a 36-D)
2) see Jim's Coins May 2007, October 2007, October 2014 ANACSAU55 cleaned, same as above ??
At least 2 are known struck on a Nicaraguan cent planchet in PCGSAU55, Mike Byers, Heritage 5/07 (not sold), other ex Heritage
9/13, StacksBowers 11/15 at $7,638 PCGS62
1936-D 1) B/R 3/02 sale at $4140 as ANACSAU55, Heritage 7/02 as PCGSAU50 Sullivan 4/2018 PCGSAU55
1937-S 1) Superior 9/98as XF45. to Tony Terranova, Entlich, Stacks 3/11 (not sold) Heritage 1/12 at $3,738, Heritage 1/14 at $3055 - PCGSAU53
No date several known, Kagins had one well circulated.
There is also a 1913 type 2 nickel on a half eagle planchet Heritage 1/21 FUN PCGS AU details test cut - 37211686
Buffalo Nickels on Dime Planchets at least 9 known
1913 1) Heritage 4/10 NGC66 #2428558-001 (type 2) at $46,000
1918 1) Bob Entlich, Lustig (consigned to Sullivan offered 1/2019 at $27,000), Heritage 1/20 FUN at $14,400 PCGSAU58 #16491070 described as an 18-D in 100 Greatest Mint Errors
1920 1) Federal Coin 8/60 lot 2449, Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 FPL at $2500, Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPL at $1500, Entlich PCGSAU55
1925 1) Entlich, Stacks 3/11 at $10,063 (not sold, back on DLRC website), Heritage 1/18 FUN at $4,800 - PCGSAU50 #16977915
1929 1) Federal Coin 8/60 lot 2450, Schornstein, Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPL at $1500, Entlich PCGSAU58
1936 1) stolen from Mark Lighterman in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC62 #1886094-002
1936-S 1) Entlich, Heritage 1/11 FUN at $9,775 - PCGS62 16336282 but tooled/damaged on cheek
No date 1) S mintmark Mike Chambers, Saul Teichman in trade - PCGSAU58
2) S mintmark Bolt, Milt Cohen-Halpern FPL, Weinberg personal collection - PCGSAU58
At least 3 1919s are known struck on an Argentine 10 cent planchet StacksBowers 2013 ANA PCGS64, 2 Entlich's PCGSVF30, 3 Heritage 1/20 NGC62
Off Metal Standing Liberty Quarters
Note: List below includes some questionable pieces
On Cent planchet
1917 2 reported by Taxay, type not specified
1928 Heritage 1/04 as raw AU53, Heritage 6/04 as SEGS63, Mike Byers as NGC63BN #3374308-001, Heritage 8/11 obverse and reverse shows die breaks not known on any silver example and also alignment not 180 degrees
No date (1928) Numismatics Ltd (Weinberg), Schornstein-HIM 7/83 at $1,525, Lighterman stolen in 2001 and recovered in 2009 - NGC65BN #1886094-001 but has same reverse die break as previous in earlier state. Obverse die crack above date is off the flan on this one.
Cline - 50% off-center on struck cent which appears in 2 of Taxay's books. Fred Weinberg says it is a fake.
On Nickel planchet
1918-S struck 25% off-center (believed foreign flan) Brand #88728 !! (Leon 10/14/18 for 50 cents), Fred Schornstein NGC65
1920 Bolt, Weinberg (obverse illustrated in MECCA 8/74, top of head off flan)
On Dime planchet
1920 (2 examples) see 100 Greatest Mint Errors for one of these (Lighterman's ?)
1930 reported by Taxay
On Foreign (Peruvian 20 centavo) copper-nickel planchet
1920 Newcomer (as a pattern), Pratt collection per Federal Coin Exchange 8/60 lot 2460, Stacks 1/06 at $13,800, Mike Byers, Heritage 8/10 ANA (not sold), Heritage 3/11 at $16,100 NGC60FH #1995045-001.
Quarters on Steel Cent Planchets
1) 1944 100 Greatest Mint Errors (Lighterman's ?)
2) 1944 - Heritage 10/10 at $1,495 corroded, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 NCS'd at $6,463 AU details, corrosion removed
3) 1944 Walter-StacksBowers 8/18 ANA at $16,200 - PCGS AU details, tooled
4) no date - Leidman inventory - cleaned
5) no date D-mint - Mike Byers inventory cleaned in NCS holder
6) no date D-mint 40% off-center HIM 2/84
7) 1944-S stolen from Mark Lighterman and recovered NGC Unc detail, environment damage #1886094-006
Off Metal Walking Liberty Half Dollars
On Cent planchet
1) Steel Cent off-center ex Bolt, Milt Cohen, Halpern FPL, Schornstein - AU
2) Steel Cent ex Weinberg, Mike Byers, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $44,063, Heritage 8/15 ANA at $30,550 PCGS64 #5490115, illustrated in both error books
On Nickel planchet
1) Bolt, Milt Cohen, Schornstein, Lighterman stolen in 2001 and recovered in 2009 NGC64 #1886094-003
On Dime planchet
1) 1945 Chambers, Mike Byers, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $41,125 - NGC64 #1770643-001, #26 in 100 Greatest US Error Coins
2) Undated reported by Andy Lustig
On Quarter planchet at least 15 different confirmed as below
1941 1) Kagins 1960s auction?, HIM 11/82 Unc at $1550, Chambers, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $18,213 - NGC64 #1816391-013
2) Geyer-Heritage 11/13 NGCAU58 #3685977-002 part of mated pair at $24,675 (date not on coin)
1942 1) Schornstein-HIM 7/83 ?, 87 ANA at $688, StacksBowers 8/18 ANA at $16,200, R. Karp PCGS62 #35312056
2) Mike Byers, Heritage 1/07 (not sold), Heritage 8/07 (not sold), Geyer-Heritage 11/13 $17,625, Lustig, Sullivan, Heritage 1/20 FUN at $19,200 PCGS65 #21481491, only top of date shows, illustrated in World's Greatest Mint Errors
3) Clark Smith's Unc with strike through under eagle's breast
4) Heritage 2/12 at $13,800 NGCAU58 #3471964-001, struck on right side 4:30
5) StacksBowers 8/16 ANA at $12,338 - NGCAU58 #4344959-002, centered
one of the first 2 Unc examples probably accounts for the Bolt collection and/or Bausher (Parke-Bernet 9/69) examples.
1943 1) Clark Smith's Unc, partial date
2) Mike Chambers, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $15,275, Jon Sullivan, Saul Teichman in trade NGC64 #2087278-011
1944 1) Kosoff-B/M 11/85, B/M 8/01 at $23,000, Heritage 9/03 at $20,700, Mike Byers PCGS65 5750723 now dipped, illustrated in both error books top half of date shows.
2) reported
1947/1917 Lighterman Unc 60 only the very top of date shows
Undated 1) illustrated in World's Greatest Mint Errors PCGS63 #5490114
2) Lighterman, same as above ?
One of these is ex Cox-Stacks 4/62 lot 2150
S-mint double struck 50% off-center with indent Weinberg, Chambers, Mike Byers PCGS65 #22052557
One is also reported with 194 of date showing
On Foreign planchet
1943-S on brass Peru ½ sol ANR/Stacks 11/06 (this was accompanied by 2 double struck walkers !!) to NE Numismatics,
Heritage 1/08, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $21,150 NGC63 #43 in 100 Greatest US Error Coins
1945-S on silver El Salvador 25 centavo Mike Byers, Geyer-Heritage 11/13 at $15,275 NGC63
Taxay mentions copper-nickel as well
Dated Franklin Halves on Dimes
1953-D StacksBowers 8/11 ANA at $5,750 NGC63
1954 uniface HIM 2/84, B/M 7/02 at $11,500 as PCGSAU58, StacksBowers 11/14? PCGS62
1954-D Cox-Stacks 4/62 - Unc
1955 reported by Taxay, it is listed in circa 1958 price list that was sold on eBay
1959 reported by Taxay
1961-D HIM 2/84 ch BU with strikethrough same as Mike Byers 4/75 FPL ?
1962-D 1) NGC64 #1703073-004
2) on struck dime flipover Lyn Knight 5/11, Saul Teichman - PCGS64 #35288568
1963-D Mike Chambers, Nick Brown-StacksBowers 3/13 at $7,050, Andy-Heritage 4/14 at $7,344 NGC63 #1816391-010 was NCS'd)
Bicentennial Quarters on Cent Planchets
1) 1976-D 81 ANA resold in Herbert I Melnick's 2/83 sale
2) 1976-D Schornstein? (rim at 5:00), Herbert I Melnick 7/83 lot 741 sold for $475. It is different from the one above.
3) 1976 Weinberg FPL, Saul Teichman ~$2000 PCGS64RB - mintmark area off coin
4) 1976-D David Lawrence 5/06 inventory PCGS64BN planchet defect across top of head, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 3/13 at $3,525, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $3,840 NGC65BN #1871082-006
5) 1976-D Jim's Coins May 2007 - ANACS63BN (compare with #1 and #2 - could be a duplicate of above)
6) 1976 mint mark area off coin was offered on eBay (grenig123) 12/09, /22/20 Moloian Rare Coin Co ANACSAU50 details cleaned
7) 1976-D B/M 2009 ANA, Lustig, Heritage 1/2010 at $4,025, Heritage 7/17 at $4,465 - NGC67RB #1816881-028
8) 1976-D Heritage 10/14 at $4,113, Heritage 1/16 FUN at $3,290, Heritage 10/16 - PCGS61RD
9) 1976-D Weinberg 7/16 inventory - PCGS64RD
10) 1976-D Weinberg 1/17 inventory at $2,800, Heritage 12/20 at $2,400 PCGSAU58BN #81610691
11) Sullivan 2/17 inventory at $4000 - PCGS64RED #81725393 no date or mintmark shows
12) 1976-D Sullivan 4/17 inventory at PCGS62RD #83727422
13) 1976-D eBay (csscoinman) 11/5/18 - NGC AU details damaged #3002997-003
14) 1976-S over a struck D-mint cent Sullivan 1/2019 - PCGSPR66RED #36322128, Sullivan 5/2019 at $15,000, Mike Byers, Heritage 1/21 NGC67PRRED #4918929-001 (flipover)
15) 1976-S Weinberg 3/09 inventory PCGSPR67RB #36321359
16) 1976-S PCGS66RD #36321360
17) 1976-S over a 69-S cent Sullivan 2/19 at $18,000 NGC65RED #4915156-003
A 1976-D graded XF+ was in the Milt Cohen-Halpern FPL, another 76-D in 1983 Weinberg FPL Unc full red rim at 7:00, 81 ANA. There could be duplicates in the listing.
Bicentennial Quarters on Nickel Planchets
1) 1976 Weinberg FPL, Saul Teichman ~ $1500 PCGS64
2) eBay PCGS61 (forgot to check for mintmark)
3) 1976 Cohen-Halpern FPL, possibly same as Heritage 2010 ANA NGCAU58 at $1380
4) 1976-D Jim's Coins May 2007, Jim's July 2008, Jim's March 2009 ANACSAU58 aligned 6:30 bottom of 1776 missing
5) 1976-D PaperChaseSue 5/10/09 closing unslabbed AU ish
6) 1976-D Nick Brown, StacksBowers 3/13 at $4,406, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $5,040 NGC67 #1871084-003
7) 1976-D Weinberg 7/13, Heritage 1/17 FUN at $1,645, Sullivan PCGS62 #26468006, possibly one of above
8) 1976-D Weinberg 1/17 inventory at $3,750, Heritage 12/20 at $2,640 PCGS65 #81610690
9) 1976-D Weinberg 9/09 inventory, Heritage 1/17 FUN at $1,645 PCGSAU58 #28483044, same as #5?
10) 1976-D Weinberg 6/19 inventory at $3,500, Sullivan 1/20 inventory at $3,500 PCGS64 #37953856
11) 1976-D Sullivan 4/20 inventory at $2700 NGC62 #4837430-004
12) 1976-S PCGSPR68 #36322129
13) 1976-S Weinberg 3/09 inventory - PCGSPR66 #36322130
14) 1976-S NGC69 double struck #4915156-002
15) 1976-S double struck Sullivan 6/19 inventory NGC66 #4837411-005
See 1976 - Weinberg Summer 1984 FPL
Bicentennial Quarters on Dime Planchets
1) 1976-P Schornstein's ?, Herbert I Melnick 7/83 lot 742 sold for $450. It sold for less than the cent in the same sale !! This coin shows some date (tops of 1776) and touches the collar at 7:30 - 8:00.
2) Weinberg 12/2000 Fixed price list at $2100
3) Weinberg, purchased at 2002 ANA, the one Mike Byers was trying to get for me prior to ANA PCGS64
4) One piece with counterbrockage obverse - stolen from Mark Lighterman
5) 1976-S Sullivan offered at $14,000 PCGSPR68 83670476, clashed dies, apparently the piece known to Mike Chambers.
6) 1976-S struck over a 1967 dime - Mike Byers March 2020, Heritage 1/21 NGC67 #4837433-001
7) 1976-S rotational double struck over a struck dime Mike Byers July 2020, Heritage 1/21 PCGS67 #39031239
8) Double denomination on struck dime ex Fivaz-B/M 2003 ANA at $7425, Heritage 1/12 at $9200, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $6,480, Heritage 12/20 at $9,000 - PCGS62 #90026149
9) With 50% indent and fissure at 3:00 in David Lawrence 5/05 inventory
10) 1976-D to Fred Weinberg 4/07 PCGS64, same as #3 ?
11) stolen from Lighterman per Mike Byers
12) Saul Teichman collection ex Mike Chambers NGC64
13) 1976-D to Nick Brown at $6463, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $6,900 NGC64 #1968865-001
There is also a 76-S struck on a small steel washer ex Jon Sullivan 1/13 NGC65, Sullivan 7/17 now NGC66, one of at least 2 known on washers
Double Struck Off-Center Bicentennial Quarters
ND 40% Schornstein, Weinberg spring 82 FPL, Nick Brown to Saul Teichman at $3200, Jon Sullivan NGC66 #1629689-013 in 100 Greatest Mint Errors #95, same as No date 40% - PCGS66 #91319334 ?
1976-D 60% Heritage 9/06 at $805 PCGSAU58
1976-D 60% with indent Heritage 1/17 FUN at $1,645 PCGS62
There are at least ½ dozen 40-60% double struck off center bicentennial half dollars.
Bicentennial Halves on Cent Planchets
1) no date, stolen from Mark Lighterman
2) 1976-D greatcollections.com 3/3/13, Saul Teichman PCGS63RB spotty, virtually full date shows
3) 1976 - Schornstein, Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPL shows left side of date, rim at 8:00, same as #1 ??
Others are known
Bicentennial Halves on Nickel Planchets
1) 1976 Weinberg website 7/2004, Saul Teichman at $3250 PCGS64, centered
2) Cohen-Halpern FPL - Gem BU, aligned rev at 7:30 no date shows
3) David Lawrence 5/2006 inventory PCGSAU58, possibly the same coin offered on eBay 4/1/2015
4) 1976 Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 (rev 12:00)
5) 1976-S Heritage 2017 FUN at $4,465 PCGSPR63 #08903720
6) 1976-S Heritage 9/19 online auction at $3,360 PCGS64 #15517877
See also Numismatics Ltd Summer 1984 FPLs
Bicentennial Halves on Dime Planchets
1) 1976-D struck over 1975-D Weinberg at $12,500 - NGC66 #2009470-005
2) No date rev touches rim at 11:00 greatcollections.com 3/3/13, Saul Teichman PCGS64
3) Reported by Mike Chambers proof, not seen !
Bicentennial Halves on Quarter Planchets
1) 1976 Cohen-Halpern FPL, B/R 1/85 Unc60, Heritage 6/04 at $3105, Saul Teichman NGC64 overgraded rev at 1:30.
2) Al's Coins raw at the time may be the piece offered 7/09 PCGS61 #4182739 rim shows at 5:00
3) David Lawrence 5/2006 inventory PCGS63
4) 1976 Jon Sullivan 1/13 FPL, Heritage 1/17 FUN at $1,293, Sullivan 6/18 inv NGC62 #3569176-015 centered (same as #2?)
5) Jon Sullivan NGC63 rev at 11:00
6) Jon Sullivan NGC61 #4465919-001 aligned at 5:00 (11:00 rim missing)
7) 1976 eBay 3/13 PCGS62 at $1250, Heritage 2/14 at $2,350 NGC62 #3569179-001 rev aligned at 1:30 similar to mine
8) 1976 AU offered to A. Lustig
See Numismatics Ltd Spring 1982 FPL rev at 1:30 (very similar to mine same as #7?) others are known, some duplication likely.
Fred has PCGS61aligned at 5 PM, same as #2?
There is also one known on brass gear ex Weinberg 1984 FPL
Bicentennial Ike Dollar on Half Dollar Planchets
1) 1976-D Weinberg 1983 FPL (type 2 rev) illustrated prior in MECCA June-July 1977
2) No date or mintmark (1976) Chambers $7000 - offered by Jim's 4/1/2013 for $11,500 PCGS65 (type 2 rev)
Ike Dollars on Cent / Copper Planchets
1) Weinberg PCGS64BN at $14,000 buyer unknown
2) Mike Byers 5/06 (well centered) PCGS64BN to Saul Teichman, illustrated in Dec 1975-Jan 1976 MECCA
3-6) private collection - all 4 believed to be DSBS
7) Known to Mike Byers, supposedly different from #1.
8) 1976 bicentennial struck 50% off-center on a struck 1976 cent Mike Chambers (see 100 Greatest Mint Errors)
9) struck over a 1973-D cent ex Camire, Modern Coin Mart 7/13 $29,325, Heritage 1/15 at $10,575 NGC66RED #2009052-003 in 100 Greatest Mint Errors
10) 1973 struck over struck cent, ex Camire, Weinberg NGC66RED #3379896-003
11) 1978 struck over struck cent StacksBowers 8/13 ANA at $15,275 NGC65RED #3379896-004
12) Dr. Berry-ANA Museum (21) - if proof probably ex 77 ANA, HIM 7/83
13) Dr. Berry-ANA Museum struck 55% off-center (73)
14) Dr. Berry-ANA Museum - Triple struck (74)
15) proof, off-center Mike Chambers, illustrated in MECCA
16) proof circa 1980 Big Apple Noe-Halpern FPL at $1495 Big Apple #9 at $1950, Sullivan 2/17 - NGCPR65BN !! - #2087278-012, Sullivan 4/17, Sullivan 4/18 NGC65PRRB #4465921-001 (NCS'd)
17) 1972-S mated pair with a dime Sullivan July 2020 inventory, Mike Byers NGC67RED #4837449-005 & NGC67 #4837449-006
18) 1971 Triple struck (last 3 digits show) ex Mike Byers April 1975 FPL, Weinberg Fall 1978 FPL, see also Weinberg 1971 FPL
19) 1990 ANA doublestruck on a Philippines 5 centimos planchet ANACS F-1322-C this or another to Dr. Berry collection (29)
20) Uniface obverse in pair with 74-D Ike it was mated with Weinberg $20,000 for the pair.
21) Uniface obverse in pair with 77-D Ike it was mated with ex Weinberg PCGS64RB
22) Uniface obverse 71-D in 100 Greatest Mint Errors
23) Uniface obverse (foreign planchet 1.73 gm) in pair with 1973-S Ike both PCGSPR67 at $40,250 Heritage 1/08, JMS coins eBay 7/2013, Greatcollections.com 9/22/13
24) Uniface obverse D-mint (spread to quarter size) Spring 1979 Weinberg FPL #9
25) Uniface reverse Fall 1978 Weinberg FPL touches rim at 11PM
26) Uniface reverse Weinberg 2012 ANA $13,000, Leo Frese website, StacksBowers 9/13 ($9500 reserve) NGC65RB
27) Uniface reverse Heritage 2/13 at $6,463 PCGS64RD
28) Uniface reverse example on cent fragment or foreign flan from Heritage 1/04 sale PCGS64BN at $8,050 and offered on Park Avenue Numismatics website in 2006-7.
Ike Dollars on Nickel Planchets
1) D-mint (1971) Dr. Berry-ANA Museum (22)
2) 1971-D StacksBowers 6/13 at $12,925 NGC64 #3586559-006
3) Reported same collection as Ike on cent and dime currently in Saul Teichman collection came from, same as #2?
4) 50% off-center on proof planchet - Pine Tree 9/74 lot 1233 gem proof.
5) 1976-D over struck 1975-D ex Camire, Weinberg $35,000 NGC66 #3385146-004
one is also known on a 6gr Taiwan planchet eBay and another was 35% off-center on 6gr Taiwan planchet PCGS64 #35272556
Ike Dollars on Dime Planchets
1) Heritage 1999 ANA (centered at bottom of ear) - ANACS62 at $3565
2) King, Warren-2003 ANA as ANACS63 (nicely centered) at $12,650, Mike Byers website, Heritage 2006 ANA at $13,800 PCGS63
3) Mike Byers 5/06 (centered at top of ear) PCGS64 to Saul Teichman
4) Mike Chambers one regular (positioned in upper left obverse)
5) Mike Chambers uniface obverse
6) Mike Chambers double struck off-center
7) Mike Byers PCGS64, double struck
8, 9) At least 2 in the Dr. Berry-ANA Museum collection, one double struck D-mint (23), the other is proof uniface (obverse), piggyback rider both shown in Judd 7th edition (80).
10) Uniface reverse Bicentennial Heritage 3/07 at $8,050 PCGS64 (see NGC66 #1999493-009)
11) Uniface reverse (centered eagle) eBay Iceman874, Mike Byers, Heritage 1/16 FUN (not sold $4700), Heritage 4/17 at $4,700 NGC65 (#4117615-015)
12) On dime scrap
13) Mark Lighterman ??
14) D-mintmark, ex Weinberg PCGS64
15) struck over struck dime, ex Camire, Weinberg NGC66 #3379896-006
16) 1974-D struck over struck 1974-D, Camire, Heritage 1/14 at $14,100, NE Numismatics offered at $18,500, Heritage 1/15 (not sold), Heritage 4/15 at $9988 NGC65 #3379896-005 now #3379873-004
17) struck over struck 1972 StacksBowers 8/13 ANA at $11,750 (after sale?) NGC66 #3379896-007
18) 1978-D struck over 1977-D, Mike Byers, Heritage 1/16 FUN (not sold), Heritage 4/17 at $9,988 NGC66 #3385146-007
19) 1972-S mated pair with a cent Sullivan July 2020 inventory, Mike Byers NGC67RED #4837449-005 & NGC67 #4837449-006
20) no date proof aligned at 10:00 Weinberg 7/20 inventory PCGS67 39031261 LI and part of B show
21) no date proof Sullivan 10/20 inventory NGC68 #4837461-002 12:00 alignment upper obv BE of Liberty shows
Ike Dollars on Quarter Planchets
1-3) Dr. Berry-ANA Museum double struck (77), other normal (24), 71-D with brockage on reverse by another dollar (46).
4) private collection
5) 5% off center at 10:30 Heritage 8/18 at $4,320 NGC65 #2542522-001 with reverse weak from 7:00 to 9:00
6) with 70% reverse indent Mike Byers, Heritage 1/16 FUN at $7,050, Mike Byers, Heritage 4/17 at $5,405, Sullivan 4/18, Heritage 1/21 - PCGS64 #32076355
7) struck over 1973 ex Camire, Weinberg $35,000 - NGC67 #3385146-008
8) Bicentennial - Dr. Berry, plated in Judd (type 2 rev)
9) Bicentennial - Heritage 9/11 at $8,050 to Saul Teichman NGC64, different from above as motto not visible (type 1 rev)
10) Bicentennial struck over bicentennial quarter - ex Camire, Weinberg, Modern Coin Mart 7/13 at $35,649, Heritage 1/14 at $28,200, Heritage 4/14 ($19,500 reserve not sold), Heritage 8/14 at $27,025 - NGC64 #2009052-001
The ANA museum also has a bicentennial ike doublestruck on bowtie scrap
SBA's on Cent Planchets
Copper
2-3 dozen 1979-S,
1979-P on struck cent ex Camire, Weinberg, Heritage 4/16 at $9,400 NGC64RED #2009052-004
1979-S on struck cent greatcollections.com 6/7/20 PCGS64RB #38337973
1979-S uniface broadstruck greatcollections.com 8/2/20 at $3,825 PCGS64RED #38337971
at least one 1980-D
at least 2 known 1980-S, one is ANACS60BN, another GreatCollections.com 5/17/2020 at $3,769 PCGS63RB #38337972
at least one o/c on cent planchet PCGS64RB #38337966
Zinc
1999-D, one reported
The no date with part of D showing ex 2007 ANA at $5750, Heritage 08/12 at $4,130, Heritage 1/14 at $3,819, Heritage 8/16 ANA at $3,760, Sullivan PCGS65RED is not zinc as the first star on reverse is far away from moon which is a 1979 die.
SBA's on Nickel 5 Cent Planchets
1) 79-S Weinberg at $5000 to Saul Teichman PCGS64
2) 79-S Littleton Coins PCGS64
3) 79-S with indent 2003 ANA at $4,025 to Mike Chambers.
4) 79-S Jim's October 1, 2007 MBS at $6800 PCGS65
5) 79-D on struck nickel, ex Camire, Weinberg NGC66 #3379896-008
6) 79-P on struck 78-P ex Camire, Heritage 1/14 at $15,275, NE Numismatics offered at $19,500, Weinberg, StacksBowers 11/16 at $15,275 NGC67 #3385146-010
SBA's on Dime Planchets
1) 79-S Weinberg FPL at $5000 to Littleton to Saul Teichman at $7500 PCGS64
2) 79-S Heritage 1/04 at $10,063 PCGS65 #5790453
3) 79-S greatcollections.com 8/2/20 at $7,538 - PCGS66 #38337968 (only mintmark shows, no date)
4) 79-P on struck dime, ex Camire, Weinberg NGC66 #3379896-009
5) 79-D on struck 78-D ex Camire, Weinberg, Heritage 4/16 at $11,750 NGC66 #2009052-005
SBA's on Struck Quarters
1) 79-P Mike Chambers PCGS66 See 100 Greatest Mint Errors
2) 79-P on 78-P ex Camire, Weinberg, Heritage 4/16 at $14,100 - NGC66 #2009052-006
3) 99-P on Georgia Heritage 8/06, 6/07, 1/08, 1/09 NGC63, flipover
4) 99-P on Georgia Heritage 1/12 at $6,325 PCGS64
5) 99-P die cap on Georgia
SBA's on Sacagawea Planchets "Golden Susies"
1) Heritage 1/02 - PCGS65 5740912 appears to be same as Phil Barnhart, B/M 1/03 at $9200 PCGS65, ping near wing on reverse.
2) ANR 1/04 at $10,350, Heritage 2/20 at $12,000 PCGS65 #2713453 scratches/toning lines are pretty obvious
3) B/M 7/02 at $13,800 PCGS66
4) Superior 10/00 ICG67 Not Sold
5) Rich Schemmer seen at 11/03 Wespnex NGC65 at $25,000 same as (1999-D) Stacks-Bowers 9/11 at $7763
6) Heritage 1/04 at ($16,100 not really sold), Heritage 1/05 at $12,650, Heritage 1/20 at $16,800 PCGS66 #3601783
7) Broadstruck ex Mike Byers
8) 2006 FUN Sale at $16,100 PCGS64 #5833877
9) StacksBowers 2013 ANA at $9,400 NGC64 (Nick Brown - #3103791)
10) Heritage 8/19 ANA at $15,600 PCGS64 #8413595, possibly one of above.
11) Superior 5/07, Heritage 8/07, Heritage 9/07 at $9,775 - PCGS64 #10707097
Sacagawea's on Cent Planchets
1) 2000 - Offered on eBay in April 2008 at $17,811 to Fred Weinberg, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 8/19 ANA at $22,800 PCGS66RED #12367564 / NGC67RED #3211150-001, falsely reoffered on eBay in October 2008
There are also Sac dollars deliberately overstruck with cent dies see pieces de caprice at end of listing
Sacagawea's on Nickel 5 Cent Planchets
1) 2001 eBay 11/08 paperchasesue, $13,667, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 8/19 ANA, Saul Teichman NGC61 #3103791-011
2) 2001 eBay 12/19 consigned to Mike Byers PCGS64 16127149
3) 2005 - Illustrated in Mike Byers Mint Error News Magazine - ANACS64
4) Undated or incomplete date reported by Mike Byers and Weinberg, unconfirmed
Sacagawea's on Dime Planchets
Uniface reverse on struck 2001 clad dime piggyback reported by Dave Camire with illustration
Reported by Mike Byers in an ANACS holder
Sacagawea's on Quarter Planchets - non 2000 dated
1) 2001 Ohio Error Collection, Heritage 5/07 (not sold), Heritage 1/09 at $5,750, Nick Brown, Heritage 2/13 at $4,406 NGC64
2) 2002-D - Ohio Error Collection, Heritage 1/09 at $8,050, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 8/13 ANA, 11/14, 4/15 Iauction NGC66
3) 2009 eBay - ANACS65 at $7,200 reoffered at same price 7/11, Jon Sullivan, Heritage 10/16 at $5,260, Saul Teichman PCGS64 #24599549
Sacagawea's on Struck Quarter non Maryland
1) On Massachusetts Mike Byers, Heritage 4/17 at $8,813 PCGS63 #83287244
Sacagawea's on SBA Planchets "Clad Sacs"
1) Mike Byers to Phil Barnhart PCGS67 sold in B/M 1/03 sale for $8050
2) Mike Byers to Tim Bullard PCGS67
3) Mike Byers to Saul Teichman ~ $9500 sold to Daniel Wendt for $17,500 PCGS66
4) Heritage 7/02 at $6038 as PCGSAU58 #5853099, Weinberg PCGS64
5) Rich Schemmer seen at 11/03 Wespnex NGC63
6) Heritage 1/04 at $12,075 PCGS68 #5790922
7) Ohio collection, David Lawrence PCGS67, Heritage 2006 ANA at $9,200 #21078030, possibly one of above
8) Mike Byers 7/2006 PCGS64 (same as #4?)
9) Heritage 9/08 - $10,925 as ANACSAU58, Heritage 6/13 at $9,106, Heritage 8/16 ANA at $7,638 PCGSAU58 #13278752 (scratches under LI in Liberty)
One was offered by Mike Byers in Heritage 2010 ANA PCGS66 #2722818 at $8,050 (same as #3?), another in StacksBowers 8/12 ANA at $16,450 NGC68 and a second NGC68 in Nick Brown collection to 2013 ANA #3103791-010 at $9,988
There is also a 2011-D Sac on steel washer PCGS65 on eBay Dec 2011 by E-adventure II/Paperchasesue
Presidential Dollars
On Nickel Planchet
1) Washington Weinberg, Mike Byers, Saul Teichman PCGS66
2) Adams - sold on eBay for $16,100, Nick Brown, StacksBowers 3/13 (10K reserve, not sold), StacksBowers 8/13 ANA at $8,813 - PCGS67
On Dime Planchet
1) Monroe sold on eBay July 2011 at $11,200, Weinberg PCGS65
On Struck Nickel
1) Washington GreatCollection.com 9/12 online auction at $14,410, Mike Byers-Heritage 1/16 FUN at $17,625 - PCGS64 #26001199
Note: Those from 2007 are likely D-mint coins
Off Metal State Quarters
On Cent planchet
Ge Lighterman - NGC65RED illustrated in 100 Greatest Mint Errors.
NC 2-3 known
On Nickel planchet late dates
2005-P Minn NGC64 #2651267-023 Sullivan 3/16 FPL at $1500, Saul Teichman at $975
2006-P Nebraska - Jon Sullivan 11/2015 - PCGS65
2007-D Wy eBay 11/11 at $699, Saul Teichman - NGC65 #3507400-083
2007-D Montana GreatCollections.com 8/2012 online auction at $1,073 PCGS64
GreatCollection.com 9/2012 online auction at $1,238 PCGS65
GreatCollection.com 9/2012 online auction at $1,019 PCGS64
2008-P Az 1) Jim MBS, later to Sullivan 12/15 PCGS66
2) Jon Sullivan 2012 offering - PCGS62
2010 Yosemite
1) Fred Weinberg eBay 5/14 at $2,125 PCGS65 #29550850
2) Fred Weinberg offered at $2700 - PCGS66 #29550851
3) Fred Weinberg 9/19 offered at $4,250, Heritage 4/20 at $2,880 - PCGS62 #37826465
On Dime planchet at least 13 states and at least 15 pieces known
Cal 2005-P Jon Sullivan offered at $6,900 PCGS65
Conn Jon Sullivan 1/17 offered at $7500 NGC62 #1608777-001 struck through grease
De one sold on eBay, possibly a second exists, one is NGC64 - #1293472-001
Ge reported by Mike Byers
In Heritage 11/02 at $4,025 PCGS64 #21228307
Ky 2001-D, Weinberg
Md Heritage 9/07 at $6,325 PCGS64 #22082248
NC Lighterman NGC66
NJ 1999-D Lighterman NCS Unc details environmental damage
NY- uniface, sold on eBay
PA NGC64 #1273333-002
Tenn at least 2 known from Weinberg FPL, one of these a D-mint, struck at 6:00 ex Heritage 9/02 NGC65 #1656225-007 at $4830, other PCGS64 #21152371 (called 2002-P but likely a D that area of the coin is off the flan)
Vir at least 2 known both NGC64, 1) Warren, 2003 ANA (not sold) coin is on rim at 7:00, 2) #1601492-007 on NGC website better centered than the first
State Quarter Double Denominations
On Struck Cent
Idaho 2007-D - Mike Byers, Saul Teichman PCGS66RED #13531462
Montana 2007-D GreatCollections.com 8/26/2012 online auction at $13,750, Sullivan PCGS65RB #26004426
On Struck Nickel
Georgia see Errorscope magazine cover, same as Sullivan 11/15 PCGS64
Maryland PCGS65 #31909028 eBay June 2015 - $1499
South Carolina 1) ex Glen Burger, 2) 2003 ANA double struck and rotated
Texas Jon Sullivan
Montana 2007-D Heritage 9/09 at $3,220 NGC67
- GreatCollections.com 9/12 at $6,325, reoffered 1/17 at $1,595, 1/14/18 at $3094, Sullivan PCGS64 #26004416
- GreatCollections.com 10/12 at $3,850, Sullivan 11/15, Heritage 9/19 online sale at $1,680 PCGS65 #26001223
- GreatCollections.com 11/12 at $2,585, greatcollections.com 7/13-4/15, Sullivan PCGS64 #26001211
On Struck Dime
Connecticut NGC67, Jon Sullivan offered at $16,000
Hawaii sold on eBay for over $13,000
New Jersey NGC67, Lighterman
Non-State Quarters on Zinc Cent Planchets
1985 off-center on struck cent - splayed see 100 Greatest Mint Errors.
1989 Heritage 12/11 at $2,703 after sale, Heritage 1/18 FUN at $2,280 NGC63RED #1816306-003
1994 off-center on planchet brockaged by quarter ex Chambers, Jon Sullivan NGC63RED
1995 Chambers, Jim's 7/11 MBS, Saul Teichman at $2,250 NGC65RED
1998 - Heritage 2011 FUN, Saul Teichman at $1,840 PCGS65
2 undated seen, one was in a Jim's Coins MBS, See Heritage 4/14 at $411 NGC63BN (is this a Silverstone coin ?)
Some Other Neat Double Denominations
1973-D half struck over a 1972-D cent Camire, Weinberg $11,500 NGC66RED #2009470-002
1973 half struck over a cent NGC66RED - Camire #3385146-002
1977-P half struck over a 1976 nickel Camire, Weinberg, Heritage 1/16 FUN at $6,169 NGC66 #2009470-004
No date half struck over a 1972-D nickel Camire, Modern Coin Mart 7/13 for $5450, Heritage 1/14 at $5,288 NGC66 #3379896-001, #2009470-006
No date half struck over a 1973-D nickel Camire - NGC66 #3379896-002, #2009470-003
1973-D half struck over a 1972-D quarter Camire, Weinberg, Sullivan, Heritage 4/16 at $11,750 NGC67 #2009470-007
1980-P half struck over a 1979 SBA Camire, Weinberg, Heritage 1/16 FUN at $22,325 NGC65 #3385146-001
2005-P nickel struck over a struck cent eBay at $5650, Heritage 9/13 withdrawn NGC68RED
2014-P cent struck over struck dime Sullivan - PCGS64 #31404932
2014-P nickel on dime Sullivan offered at $4500 NGC63 #2659678-005
2017-P nickel struck over struck dime, Sullivan, Saul Teichman in trade PCGS65 #35684603
Double Denomination and other Pieces de Caprice
1965 SMS dime struck onto a quarter planchet - PCGS64 #83670234
1973-D cent saddle struck on quarter planchet - Sullivan 2016 inventory - PCGSAU55 #80648515
1981 cent uniface struck on half dollar planchet - Heritage 8/16 at $8,225 - NGC60 #4253920-001
1981 cent struck 70% off-center on 1979 SBA dollar - Mike Byers - PCGS #31862446
2000 Double Headed nickel weekly struck - Mike Byers, Heritage 2017 FUN - PCGS65 #81049724
2000 quarter planchet struck by cent dies - PCGS65 #81049723
2000 New Hampshire quarter struck by cent dies - at least 6 known as listed
PCGS65 #28749014 - Heritage 1/16 at $9,400
PCGS65 #80691522 - Mike Byers
PCGS66 #80691523 flipover - Mike Byers
PCGS65 #85164358 - Jon Sullivan offering 12/17 at $12,500
PCGS64 #30326918 - Jon Sullivan offering 8/19 at $12,000
PCGS63 #31862447 - Mike Byers on eBay 11/2019 offered at $17,500
2000 Virginia quarter struck by cent dies, Weinberg - PCGS65 #80691524, flipover PCGS66 at $15,600 #35284315
2000 Sac dollar by cent dies 1) Heritage 7/15 at $35,250 - PCGS66 #28791037
2) Mike Byers - eBay 11/19 offered at $35,000 - PCGS63 #31862448 flipover
3) QDB - StacksBowers 6/20 at $38,400 - PCGS66 #32761783
2001 Sac dollar by cent dies - Jon Sullivan 11/16 - PCGS66 #80691521 offered at $22,500
